---
title: "Academic publishers face class action over ‘peer review’ pay, other restrictions"
description: "A UCLA professor has filed a class action lawsuit against six major academic publishers, alleging antitrust violations by prohibiting simultaneous submissions and not compensating for peer review serv"
type: "news"
locale: "en"
url: "https://longbridge.com/en/news/214314091.md"
published_at: "2024-09-13T17:07:32.000Z"
---

# Academic publishers face class action over ‘peer review’ pay, other restrictions

> A UCLA professor has filed a class action lawsuit against six major academic publishers, alleging antitrust violations by prohibiting simultaneous submissions and not compensating for peer review services. The lawsuit claims this practice constitutes unlawful price-fixing and reduces competition for manuscripts. The publishers, including Elsevier and Wiley, reportedly earned over $5 billion in 2023 from peer-reviewed journals. The case seeks class-action status for potentially hundreds of thousands of scholars affected by these practices.

By Mike Scarcella

Sept 13 (Reuters) - A University of California Los Angeles neuroscience professor has sued six major academic journal publishers, claiming in a proposed class action that they violated antitrust law by barring simultaneous submissions to multiple journals and denying pay for “peer review” services.

Professor Lucina Uddin filed the lawsuit in Brooklyn federal court on Thursday against Elsevier, John Wiley & Sons, Sage Publications, Springer Nature, Taylor & Francis and Wolters Kluwer.

Scholarly journal submissions are reviewed by other experts in the author’s field to vet their submissions for publication and comment on their findings. Uddin said that the practice of not paying scholars for peer reviews amounted to unlawful price-fixing.

The lawsuit also said the publishers unlawfully agreed not to compete with each other for manuscripts, reducing any incentive to review and publish work more quickly.

Wiley in a statement said the claims “are without merit.” Wolters Kluwer, Elsevier and the other defendants declined to comment or did not immediately respond to a request for one.

Dean Harvey, a lawyer for Uddin, said in a statement that the for-profit academic publishing industry had earned billions “exploiting the goodwill and hard work of brilliant scholars, and of taxpayers who foot the bill to create their product.”

The lawsuit said the publishing defendants in 2023 collectively received more than $10 billion in revenue from their peer-reviewed journals.

Uddin has been a professor in UCLA’s psychology department since July 2023. Her complaint said she has published more than 175 academic articles and provided peer review services for more than 150 journals.

The lawsuit seeks class-action status for an estimated “hundreds of thousands” of class members.

“It has become increasingly difficult to coerce busy scholars into providing their valuable labor for nothing,” Uddin said, and manuscripts can sit awaiting peer review for months or years.

Her lawsuit also challenged what it called a “gag” rule that bars scholars from freely sharing scientific advancements in their manuscripts while they are under peer review.

Scholars often must sign away intellectual property rights to their work in exchange for nothing, the lawsuit said, while the publishers charge “the maximum the market will bear for access to that scientific knowledge.”

The case is Dr. Lucina Uddin v. Elsevier BV et al, U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York, No. 1:24-cv-06409.

For plaintiffs: Dean Harvey of Lieff Cabraser Heimann & Bernstein, and Benjamin Elga of Justice Catalyst Law

For defendants: No appearances yet

### Related Stocks

- [WLY.US - John Wiley & Son](https://longbridge.com/en/quote/WLY.US.md)

## Related News & Research

| Title | Description | URL |
|-------|-------------|-----|
| Wiley and CAUL Sign Three-Year Open Access Publishing Agreement | John Wiley & Sons Inc. has signed a three-year open access publishing agreement with the Council of Australasian Univers | [Link](https://longbridge.com/en/news/272326564.md) |
| Wiley Expects Learning Segment Revenue to Decline Despite Moderating Headwinds | John Wiley & Sons Inc. anticipates a decline in Learning segment revenue, despite moderating headwinds. The company is f | [Link](https://longbridge.com/en/news/268638385.md) |
| Wiley Boosts Fiscal 2026 Share Repurchase Allocation to $100 Million USD | John Wiley & Sons Inc. has increased its Fiscal 2026 share repurchase allocation to $100 million, up from $60 million in | [Link](https://longbridge.com/en/news/269229232.md) |
| Wiley Extends Publishing Partnership With The Physiological Society Through 2036 | John Wiley & Sons Inc. and The Physiological Society have extended their publishing partnership through 2036. This agree | [Link](https://longbridge.com/en/news/269097359.md) |
| Wiley Renews Publishing Partnership with British Educational Research Association | John Wiley & Sons Inc. has renewed its publishing partnership with the British Educational Research Association (BERA) f | [Link](https://longbridge.com/en/news/262288865.md) |

---

> **Disclaimer**: This article is for reference only and does not constitute any investment advice.
