---
title: "Goldman Sachs: Bank stock valuations have partially absorbed pessimistic expectations, with Citigroup and Morgan Stanley becoming the focus of attention"
description: "Goldman Sachs' research report released on April 9, 2025, pointed out that the shares of large U.S. banks have cumulatively fallen by 25%, mainly due to economic uncertainty. Although the price-to-boo"
type: "news"
locale: "en"
url: "https://longbridge.com/en/news/235397821.md"
published_at: "2025-04-10T10:03:06.000Z"
---

# Goldman Sachs: Bank stock valuations have partially absorbed pessimistic expectations, with Citigroup and Morgan Stanley becoming the focus of attention

> Goldman Sachs' research report released on April 9, 2025, pointed out that the shares of large U.S. banks have cumulatively fallen by 25%, mainly due to economic uncertainty. Although the price-to-book ratio is close to the long-term average, it is still higher than the lows during economic recessions. Goldman Sachs analyzed six major downside risks and estimated that the earnings per share (EPS) of large banks could face about a 45% downside risk by 2026, with ROTCE potentially declining by about 8 percentage points. PNC and Bank of America have the largest EPS downside risks, at 19% and 17%, respectively

According to the Zhitong Finance APP, Goldman Sachs released an in-depth research report on the U.S. banking industry on April 9, 2025, reassessing the downside scenario for large banks. Since the peak in February 2025, large bank stocks have cumulatively fallen by 25%, primarily driven by uncertainties regarding the impact of tariffs on the economy, leading to a slowdown in loan growth, a flattening yield curve, a weak capital market, and deteriorating credit quality.

Goldman Sachs believes that although the current price-to-tangible book value (P/TBV) of large banks has fallen from its peak to around 1.4 times, close to the long-term average level, it is still higher than the lows reached during previous economic recessions (approximately 0.3 to 0.4 times). In a pessimistic scenario, banks can still achieve an ROTCE (Return on Tangible Common Equity) of about 8.5%, higher than the 7.5% during past recessions, which may provide some support for bank stocks.

## Six Major Downside Drivers: Quantitative Shock and Bank Differentiation

Goldman Sachs detailed six downside risk factors in the report and their impact on expected earnings for 2026, estimating that large banks could face about a 45% downside risk to their earnings per share (EPS) in 2026, with average ROTCE potentially declining by about 8 percentage points.

![4af2f3b90593ef25934d620532133c1.png](https://imageproxy.pbkrs.com/https://img.zhitongcaijing.com/image/20250410/1744278188284949.png?x-oss-process=image/auto-orient,1/interlace,1/resize,w_1440,h_1440/quality,q_95/format,jpg)

Figure 1

**Flattening Yield Curve**

Since the beginning of the year, the yields on 5-year and 10-year U.S. Treasury bonds have decreased by approximately 55 and 40 basis points, respectively. If the 5-year U.S. Treasury yield in 2025 and 2026 is 100 basis points lower than the current forward curve expectations, bank net interest income could decline by 3% and 10%, respectively, leading to EPS declines of 4% and 15%. Among the banks, PNC Financial Services Group (PNC.US) and Bank of America (BAC.US) face the largest EPS downside risks, at 19% and 17%, respectively, while JPMorgan Chase (JPM.US) has relatively smaller EPS downside risk.

![d149dca557938dab55ee6514905c39e.png](https://imageproxy.pbkrs.com/https://img.zhitongcaijing.com/image/20250410/1744278214706001.png?x-oss-process=image/auto-orient,1/interlace,1/resize,w_1440,h_1440/quality,q_95/format,jpg)

Figure 2

**Weak Capital Market Revenue**

In the investment banking sector, assuming a 20 percentage point slowdown in growth, this would lead to a 1% decline in EPS and a 20 basis point reduction in ROTCE. Specifically, Morgan Stanley (MS.US) could see a 2% decline in EPS, while Wells Fargo (WFC.US) might only experience a 0.3% decline, indicating significant differentiation among banks ![5fc81295b7a3e319c890befd4206415.png](https://imageproxy.pbkrs.com/https://img.zhitongcaijing.com/image/20250410/1744278574296337.png?x-oss-process=image/auto-orient,1/interlace,1/resize,w_1440,h_1440/quality,q_95/format,jpg)

Figure 3

**Decline in Trading Revenue**

Goldman Sachs expects trading revenue to decline by 8%, leading to a 2% drop in EPS and a 40 basis point decrease in ROTCE. Assuming a year-on-year decline in trading revenue of 4% (similar to levels in 2013-2014), it is expected to result in a 2% reduction in EPS and a 40 basis point drop in return on tangible common equity (ROTCE). In this scenario, Citigroup's (C.US) EPS may decline by 4%, while JP Morgan's EPS may decrease by 3%, indicating significant risk exposure.

![448157963782cebdf41f7016f7758fe.png](https://imageproxy.pbkrs.com/https://img.zhitongcaijing.com/image/20250410/1744278586419439.png?x-oss-process=image/auto-orient,1/interlace,1/resize,w_1440,h_1440/quality,q_95/format,jpg)

Figure 4

**Deterioration in Credit Quality**

Goldman Sachs estimates that in a recession scenario, the bad debt ratio for large banks could reach 125 basis points, approximately 65 basis points higher than current levels, based on historical average loss rates, macro stress testing models, and the DFAST loss estimates of the companies. Based on the composition of the loan portfolio, Citigroup and JP Morgan may face the highest loss rates.

Goldman Sachs believes that the market may have partially digested these higher loss rates, but PNC Financial Services Group, Bank of America, and JP Morgan may face the greatest risk of earnings downgrades, while Morgan Stanley is least affected by losses. Goldman Sachs estimates that the increase in bad debts could lead to about a 15% decline in EPS and approximately a 230 basis point drop in ROTCE.

**Slowdown in Loan Growth**

An economic slowdown may impact loan growth in the second half of 2025, with certain categories (such as commercial and industrial loans) potentially experiencing negative growth. Goldman Sachs assessed the impact of loan growth being 2 percentage points lower than expected in 2025, estimating it could lead to a 2% decline in net interest income, a 3% drop in EPS, and a 40 basis point decrease in ROTCE. Among them, Citigroup faces the highest EPS downside risk at 4%, while Morgan Stanley has the lowest EPS downside risk.

**Suspension of Stock Buybacks**

Goldman Sachs assumes that banks will suspend stock buybacks until the end of 2026, which could lead to an 8% decline in EPS and approximately a 170 basis point drop in ROTCE. Citigroup and Bank of America are most affected, with EPS impacts of about 12% each.

## Valuation Analysis

Goldman Sachs believes that although bank stocks have fallen 17% since the beginning of the year, valuations are only marginally attractive. The average price-to-book ratio for large banks is 1.4 times, slightly above historical lows. Goldman Sachs also analyzed two valuation methods, P/TBV and P/PPOP, suggesting that in the current economic environment, the market may prefer valuation methods based on book value **P/TBV Valuation**

Goldman Sachs pointed out that the P/TBV of large banks has fallen from a high of 1.9 times after the 2024 presidential election to 1.4 times, slightly above the lowest level of 1.3 times on April 4. Goldman Sachs also compared the valuation gap between high ROE banks and low ROE banks, finding that this gap has compressed from 19.6 to 14.9. Based on the regression analysis of 2026E PTBV and ROTCE, Bank of America and U.S. Bancorp (USB.US) are the cheapest in terms of valuation, while the USB valuation adjusted for AOCI impact is the most attractive.

**P/PPOP Valuation**

Goldman Sachs noted that the current P/PPOP multiple is 7.4 times, still above the average level of 7.1 times since 1991 (excluding 2008/2009). In recession periods without capital shortages (such as the early 2000s), the low point for P/PPOP was 6 times, while in capital shortage periods, the low point for P/PPOP was 3-4 times. Goldman Sachs adjusted the expected bad debt ratio and added actual bad debts back into P/PPOP, finding that the current valuation is 7.6 times, which still has certain attractiveness compared to the average level of 7.5 times and the low point of 4 times in the last cycle.

## Market Expectations and Investment Recommendations

Goldman Sachs believes that the market seems to have priced in about 45-50% of the pessimistic scenario. Goldman Sachs also analyzed the performance of different banks under pessimistic scenarios, believing that Citigroup, U.S. Bancorp, and Morgan Stanley are the most attractive at current valuations. Additionally, Goldman Sachs pointed out that the 7-year U.S. Treasury yield has fallen by about 50 basis points so far this year, which could bring an 11 basis point increase to banks' CET1 ratios and about a 120 basis point increase to tangible book value

### Related Stocks

- [PNC.US - PNC Financial Services](https://longbridge.com/en/quote/PNC.US.md)
- [C.US - Citigroup](https://longbridge.com/en/quote/C.US.md)
- [GS.US - Goldman Sachs](https://longbridge.com/en/quote/GS.US.md)
- [BAC.US - Bank of America](https://longbridge.com/en/quote/BAC.US.md)
- [MS.US - Morgan Stanley](https://longbridge.com/en/quote/MS.US.md)
- [JPM.US - JPMorgan Chase](https://longbridge.com/en/quote/JPM.US.md)
- [USB.US - US Bancorp](https://longbridge.com/en/quote/USB.US.md)
- [WFC.US - Wells Fargo](https://longbridge.com/en/quote/WFC.US.md)

## Related News & Research

| Title | Description | URL |
|-------|-------------|-----|
| 花旗警告：英镑 “最脆弱时刻” 在 5 月，政治动荡与降息预期令其双重承压 | 花旗策略师 Daniel Tobon 表示，未来两个月英国政局不确定性与央行降息预期将共振，对英镑构成显著下行压力。他称，真正的做空窗口将在 5 月初地方选举前夕开启，4、5 月两大主题交汇将触发英镑 “更大幅度反应”。他预计英央行 4 月 | [Link](https://longbridge.com/en/news/275630616.md) |
| 花旗集团表示已签署并完成了将 AO Citibank，即花旗集团之前的俄罗斯子公司，出售给 Renaissance Capital 的交易 | 2 月 18 日（路透社）- 花旗集团：已签署并完成将花旗银行（Citi 的前俄罗斯子公司）出售给复兴资本的交易；花旗集团：此次交易使花旗完全退出其在俄罗斯的业务，包括所有剩余的业务，以及大约 800 名员工；花旗集团：预计此次剥离将在 2 | [Link](https://longbridge.com/en/news/276234739.md) |
| PNC 金融服务集团公司收购了阿里巴巴集团控股有限公司 3,223 股股票 $BABA | PNC 金融服务集团在第三季度将其在阿里巴巴集团的持股比例增加了 7.1%，额外购买了 3,223 股，总持股量达到 48,759 股，价值 870 万美元。其他投资者也调整了在阿里巴巴的持仓。该股票开盘价为 155.91 美元，过去一年的 | [Link](https://longbridge.com/en/news/276318339.md) |
| PNC 金融服务｜8-K：2025 财年 Q4 营收 60.71 亿美元 |  | [Link](https://longbridge.com/en/news/272829273.md) |
| 美国银行业正迎来史上最疯狂 “抱团取暖”，谁能挑战摩根大通与美银？ | 美国银行业迎来 “抱团取暖” 式并购潮，如 PNC 以 41 亿美元、Fifth-Third 以 109 亿美元收购同业，试图挑战摩根大通与美银的主导地位。此轮热潮由监管松绑与资本充裕驱动，核心悬念在于摆脱束缚的富国银行会否重返战场，从而真 | [Link](https://longbridge.com/en/news/273375974.md) |

---

> **Disclaimer**: This article is for reference only and does not constitute any investment advice.