--- title: "Marvell vs. Coherent: One AI Stock Made the Deal, One May Collect the Payoff, Says Top Investor" type: "News" locale: "en" url: "https://longbridge.com/en/news/305032044.md" description: "Top investor Julia Ostian rates Coherent a Buy and Marvell a Hold, citing Marvell's acquisition of Lumentum as dilutive and risky. While both companies benefit from AI data center growth, Ostian believes Coherent is undervalued compared to Marvell and positioned to gain customers lost by Lumentum. Despite strong financials for both, she avoids Marvell due to deal uncertainty and valuation gaps." datetime: "2026-11-10T14:16:33.000Z" locales: - [zh-CN](https://longbridge.com/zh-CN/news/305032044.md) - [en](https://longbridge.com/en/news/305032044.md) - [zh-HK](https://longbridge.com/zh-HK/news/305032044.md) generator: "portal-rs" --- # Marvell vs. Coherent: One AI Stock Made the Deal, One May Collect the Payoff, Says Top Investor The AI build-out has made light one of the most valuable commodities in tech. Inside data centers, chips now talk to each other through lasers instead of copper wire. **Marvell Technology (NASDAQ:MRVL)** and **Coherent (NYSE:COHR)** are both at the center of that shift, but they come at it from opposite ends. Marvell designs the chips that process optical signals, while Coherent makes the lasers. That line got blurrier this month, when Marvell agreed to buy Coherent’s closest rival, Lumentum, in an all-stock deal. Investors didn’t like it, and Marvell shares, already well off their summer peak, fell sharply again. 5-star investor Julia Ostian thinks the deal changes the picture for both stocks, just not in Marvell’s favor. The reasoning behind the deal is simple. Marvell has no laser production of its own and buys from outside suppliers, Lumentum among them, while lasers are in desperately short supply. Lumentum says its capacity is booked until nearly 2029. Owning that supply also protects Marvell against co-packaged optics, a design that could reduce the need for some of its signal-processing chips. The problem, in the investor’s view, is that some of Lumentum’s buyers, like Ciena and Cisco, compete with Marvell and may now want another supplier. Ostian sees Coherent as the obvious independent choice. Nvidia has put $2 billion into each of the three companies, but with Lumentum heading into a business that designs rival chips, the investor wouldn’t be surprised to see Nvidia lean more on Coherent. Coherent CEO Jim Anderson made the same pitch on the latest earnings call, saying it’s “really important” for customers to have “an independent photonic optical supplier.” Coherent is doing well regardless. Fiscal Q1 revenue rose 50% year over year to $2.37 billion. Datacenter & Communications grew 79% and now makes up 82% of sales. The fastest-growing piece is the business that links data centers to one another, which nearly quadrupled YoY and is now running at close to $1 billion a year. Non-GAAP EPS jumped 80% to $2.09, and operating margin widened to 23% from 19.5%. For the current quarter, Coherent guided for revenue of $2.55 billion to $2.75 billion and EPS of $2.28 to $2.48. Management expects full-year growth above 60%, its first $3 billion quarter by the end of this fiscal year, and a $4 billion quarter in fiscal 2028. It is also targeting a gross margin above 45% before the end of 2028. Marvell’s July quarter was also solid: revenue rose 37% YoY to $2.74 billion, with much higher margins. At its October Investor Day, management lifted its fiscal 2028 revenue outlook to about $20 billion. Much of that depends on a handful of hyperscalers, including a custom-chip deal with Google worth up to $120 billion. Adding Lumentum, whose latest quarterly revenue more than doubled YoY to $1.26 billion, would speed up growth but lower the gross margin. Even so, the combined margin would still sit well above Coherent’s. Ostian’s concern is the deal. Marvell will issue new shares equal to about half its current count, and the investor’s rough math has the deal cutting EPS by about 5% at first. It isn’t expected to close until the first half of 2028, which leaves plenty of time for regulators to get in the way. Then there’s valuation. After Monday’s rebound, Coherent trades at about 14x next year’s expected earnings, compared with roughly 21x for Marvell, and its PEG ratio is just 0.24. The gap is even wider on sales: Coherent trades at about 5.6x, against roughly 14x for both Marvell and Lumentum. Coherent earns less on each dollar of sales, so some discount is fair. Ostian just thinks the gap is far too wide, especially with Coherent’s margins rising. And at about 47x trailing earnings, Coherent still sits well below its five-year median of 73x. Ostian’s case for Coherent isn’t without risks. The company is pouring money into new capacity, with $776 million in capex last quarter alone, and that has pushed free cash flow into negative territory. And if the Marvell deal falls apart, so does the idea that Lumentum’s customers will start moving to Coherent, though the investor believes the underlying business would still be strong. Even so, Ostian has now taken a sizable position in Coherent, rating the stock a Buy. The top investor is avoiding Marvell, rating the stock a Hold for now (i.e., Neutral) because of the dilution, the deal uncertainty and the valuation. (To watch Ostian’s track record, click here.) On the Street, however, both these stocks are rated Strong Buys. COHR’s average price target lands at $359, a figure pointing to 12-month returns of 59%. MRVL is expected to gain 109%, considering its average target clocks in at $323.63. (See COHR stock forecast or MRVL stock forecast) *Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this article are solely those of the featured investor. The content is intended to be used for informational purposes only. It is very important to do your own analysis before making any investment.* ### Related Stocks - [COHR.US](https://longbridge.com/en/quote/COHR.US.md) - [MRVL.US](https://longbridge.com/en/quote/MRVL.US.md) - [COHC.US](https://longbridge.com/en/quote/COHC.US.md) - [COHH.US](https://longbridge.com/en/quote/COHH.US.md) - [COHQ.US](https://longbridge.com/en/quote/COHQ.US.md) - [COHX.US](https://longbridge.com/en/quote/COHX.US.md) - [MRVU.US](https://longbridge.com/en/quote/MRVU.US.md) - [MRVX.US](https://longbridge.com/en/quote/MRVX.US.md) - [MVLL.US](https://longbridge.com/en/quote/MVLL.US.md) - [CIEN.US](https://longbridge.com/en/quote/CIEN.US.md) - [CSCO.US](https://longbridge.com/en/quote/CSCO.US.md) - [GOOGL.US](https://longbridge.com/en/quote/GOOGL.US.md) - [LITE.US](https://longbridge.com/en/quote/LITE.US.md) - [NVDA.US](https://longbridge.com/en/quote/NVDA.US.md) ## Related News & Research - [Marvell Stock Price Forecast: Options Traders Expect a Large Move in MRVL Stock After Q3 Earnings](https://longbridge.com/en/news/306124601.md) - [Marvell Stock’s (MRVL) Plunge Is My Opportunity to Buy](https://longbridge.com/en/news/306273400.md) - [Why Wall Street called Marvell Technology a strong buy after a 30% drop](https://longbridge.com/en/news/305699325.md) - [Marvell Publishes FY26 Sustainability Report](https://longbridge.com/en/news/306308632.md) - [Marvell Stock Rises as Citadel Discloses 729% Stake Boost, Slashes SpaceX, Amazon](https://longbridge.com/en/news/305836990.md) --- > **Disclaimer: This article is for reference only and does not constitute any investment advice.**