Hilltop Earnings Call: Loan Growth, Capital Strength

Hilltop ((HTH)) has held its Q2 earnings call. Read on for the main highlights of the call.

Claim 55% Off TipRanks

• Unlock powerful investing tools with TipRanks Premium to make smarter, more confident investment decisions
• Subscribe to TipRanks Smart Investor Newsletter, and discover new investing opportunities with data-backed stock picks

Hilltop’s latest earnings call struck a cautiously optimistic tone as management balanced strong core banking and broker-dealer results against persistent mortgage and funding headwinds. Executives highlighted solid profitability, renewed loan growth momentum, expanding margins and robust capital returns, while acknowledging tougher competition for deposits, mortgage margin compression and lingering macro uncertainty around interest rates.

Consolidated Profitability

Hilltop reported net income of $36.5 million, or $0.63 per diluted share, underscoring resilient earnings power in a choppy environment. The company delivered a return on average assets of 1.0% and a return on average equity of 6.9% for the second quarter of 2026, metrics that management framed as a solid platform for future growth and ongoing capital deployment.

PlainsCapital Bank Performance

PlainsCapital Bank remained the key earnings engine, generating $51 million in pretax income while expanding its net interest margin to 3.42% at the bank level. The franchise posted a 1.30% return on average assets and maintained an efficiency ratio of 55.0%, aided by a $1 million provision release that reflected stable credit performance outside a few isolated issues.

Loan Growth and Upgraded Outlook

Period-end held-for-investment loans increased by $239 million quarter over quarter, with broad-based contributions from commercial real estate, commercial and industrial, broker-dealer and mortgage warehouse lending. On the back of this momentum, Hilltop raised its full-year 2026 expected average loan growth range to 5.0%–7.0%, excluding certain mortgage warehouse and retained mortgage impacts, signaling confidence in underlying demand.

Net Interest Income and Margin Expansion

Net interest income reached $116 million, up 5.0% from a year earlier, as Hilltop benefited from disciplined balance sheet management and improved asset yields. Consolidated net interest margin widened by 8 basis points sequentially to 3.21%, helped by lower deposit costs and a strategic shift from excess cash into higher-yielding loans.

Hilltop Securities Strength

The broker-dealer arm, Hilltop Securities, continued to be a bright spot, posting $12 million in pretax income on $124 million of net revenue for a 10.0% pretax margin. Overall broker-dealer net revenue rose 13.0% year over year, powered by a 73.0% surge in structured finance and a 10.0% gain in fixed income services, while wealth management also showed meaningful improvement.

Capital Position and Shareholder Returns

Hilltop underscored its capital firepower, with a Common Equity Tier 1 ratio of 18.3% and tangible book value per share rising to $32.36. The company returned $11.6 million to stockholders through dividends and repurchased $47 million of shares, and the board approved a 10% dividend increase to $0.22 per share alongside a larger buyback authorization for 2026.

Cost Reductions at PrimeLending

At PrimeLending, management continued to reshape the cost base to withstand a tough mortgage backdrop, cutting fixed expenses by roughly $10 million on an annualized basis versus the prior year’s second quarter. These actions are aimed at boosting operational resiliency and preserving optionality, even as volumes remain subdued and profitability pressures persist.

PrimeLending Loss and Mortgage Headwinds

PrimeLending posted a pretax loss of $2 million as the mortgage market stumbled into the summer, reflecting weaker purchase activity and higher borrowing costs. Elevated interest rates, rising property taxes and insurance, limited housing inventory and a record-low share of first-time buyers all kept originations and gain-on-sale economics under strain.

Mortgage Margins and Revenue Pressure

Mortgage gain-on-sale margins slipped to 217 basis points, down 6 basis points from a year ago, illustrating ongoing pricing competition and mix headwinds. Mortgage-related revenues fell by $1.8 million year over year, driven largely by less favorable valuation marks on the rate-lock pipeline, which compounded the profitability drag in the segment.

Deposit Base Contraction and Competition

Average total deposits stood at about $10.4 billion, down $263 million from the prior year as customers chased higher yields and alternative options. Management flagged intensifying competition that could drive higher offered rates and more exception pricing, noting that interest-bearing deposits carried a 3.27% cost and a 75% beta through the recent rate cycle, dynamics that may shift if pricing battles escalate.

Allowance for Credit Losses and Deterioration

The allowance for credit losses declined by $4 million during the quarter to $85 million, leaving bank-level ACL coverage at 1.03% of loans. However, classified and special mention balances increased due to deterioration in a single-family credit, prompting a $1.9 million rise in specific reserves and a reminder from management that the allowance could remain volatile as conditions evolve.

Net Charge-Offs and Credit Activity

Net charge-offs totaled approximately $3.2 million, equal to about 16 basis points of average loans, reflecting ongoing resolution of challenged credits rather than broad-based stress. Executives emphasized continued vigilance on credit migration trends, highlighting active workout efforts and a willingness to recognize losses where necessary to de-risk the balance sheet.

Noninterest Expense and Variable Compensation

Noninterest expenses edged up 2.0% year over year to $267 million, a move largely tied to performance-based payouts at Hilltop Securities. Strong revenue in structured finance and wealth management drove higher variable compensation, an outcome management characterized as a healthy trade-off given the incremental profitability these businesses generated.

Guidance for Broker-Dealer Fees and NIM

Looking ahead, Hilltop outlined a cautious yet constructive outlook, with broker-dealer fee revenue expected to fall within a range of roughly negative 3.0% to positive 1.0%. Net interest margin is projected to moderate and possibly slip modestly in the second half under a base case that assumes one rate increase later in 2026, though net interest income should remain relatively stable as loan growth and mix continue to support earnings.

Hilltop’s guidance points to mixed but manageable near-term trends, with raised loan growth expectations of 5.0%–7.0%, normalized loan-to-deposit targets around the mid-80% range and a clear focus on disciplined capital deployment. Management reiterated its flexibility to sustain dividends and buybacks thanks to an 18.3% CET1 ratio and rising tangible book value, even as broker-dealer fees and margins navigate rate and competitive uncertainties.

Overall, the earnings call painted a picture of a company leaning on diversified earnings, robust capital and cost discipline to offset mortgage and funding pressures. For investors, Hilltop’s story hinges on whether its growing loan book and thriving securities business can continue to outrun margin normalization and mortgage softness, while maintaining credit quality and shareholder-friendly capital returns.