期权进阶教程（六）：熟悉你的对手

Market Makers are the crucial "liquidity providers" in the options market, and indeed the entire financial market. They are not ordinary investors, but rather the "infrastructure" of the market, akin to wholesalers or intermediaries. When you buy or sell an option, your counterparty is most likely one of these market makers.

1. What is a Market Maker?

Market makers are financial institutions designated by exchanges and relevant regulatory bodies. Their legal duty is to continuously provide two-sided quotes to the futures market (simultaneously posting a bid price and an ask price). Regardless of market movements, whenever a retail investor wants to execute small batch trades, they must be ready to accept and match orders within the gap between the best bid and ask as quickly as possible.
It is precisely because of the existence of market makers that you don't need to wait for another retail investor to sell to you when buying an option, enabling "instantaneous execution."

Some novice retail investors sometimes use the derogatory term "market manipulator" to refer to this group. In reality, the presence of market makers is essential for a highly liquid market. They are the fundamental guarantee behind the common saying that the US stock market is a highly liquid one with both short and long participants.

2. What is the Profit Logic of Market Makers?

The fundamental goal of market makers is not to make money by predicting stock price movements (not betting on direction), but to earn risk-free or low-risk returns through extremely high-frequency trading and tiny price spreads. Their main sources of profit include:

1. Earning the Bid-Ask Spread:
   This is the core profit for market makers. For example, they might quote a bid price of $1.00 and an ask price of $1.05 for an option. When Investor A sells to the market maker at $1.00, and Investor B buys from the market maker at $1.05, the market maker makes a $0.05 profit. Although the profit per trade is razor-thin, with daily volumes in the tens of millions, this translates into an enormous revenue stream.
2. Time Value Decay (Earning Theta):
   Retail investors tend to like buying options (Long positions), while market makers are typically the passive sellers (Short). Options lose time value every day. By holding these short positions and hedging the risks, market makers can steadily capture the time value lost by retail investors.
3. Exchange Rebates and Payment for Order Flow (PFOF):
   Because market makers provide liquidity, exchanges pay them rebates on fees. Simultaneously, market makers also pay "Payment for Order Flow (PFOF)" to brokerages (like Robinhood) to purchase retail investors' bundled orders in bulk, averaging out the per-trade fees. Since retail investors' quotes often lack informational advantage (so-called "uninformed"), market makers can more easily profit from the spread on these trades. Additionally, the reason brokerages like Robinhood$Robinhood(HOOD.US) and Charles Schwab can offer zero commissions to clients is precisely because the liquidity provided by these market makers can be packaged and sold for profit.
4. Ultra-Fast Information Arbitrage (Volatility Arbitrage, etc.):
   With microsecond-level trading speeds and massive data, market makers can instantly spot mispricing between implied and realized volatility, or tiny price discrepancies across exchanges, enabling risk-free arbitrage.

3. Do Market Makers Hold Until Expiration?

Market makers are extremely averse to directional risk, so they must "hedge," and this hedging mechanism profoundly impacts the market.

When a market maker sells you a call option, it nominally becomes short the underlying stock. If left unhedged, a sharp rise in the stock price could bankrupt the market maker. To eliminate this risk, they employ a strategy called Delta-Neutral:

• Dynamic Hedging: For every call option a market maker sells, they immediately buy a corresponding number of shares in the underlying stock market (determined by Delta) to hedge the risk. If the stock rises, they continue buying shares to increase the hedge; if it falls, they sell shares. This machine-driven "buying high, selling low" behavior is called dynamic hedging and often amplifies market rallies and crashes (known as "Gamma Squeeze").
• Holding Until Expiration: Market makers don't care about holding until expiration or whether the option is ultimately exercised. Their core logic is that regardless of the option's status, their holdings of the underlying stock or futures hedge must always be precisely balanced against their exposure. As the option expiration date (e.g., the monthly OpEx) approaches, they will automatically sell or buy massive amounts of hedged shares as the option's Delta decays to zero or converges, frequently causing sharp abnormal volatility in the underlying stock on expiration day (the "option expiration effect").

4. Who are the World's Most Famous Market Makers?

Option market making is an industry with extremely high barriers to entry and a high degree of oligopoly, demanding immense computing power and sophisticated quantitative models. The giants currently dominating global quantitative option market making mainly include:

1. Citadel Securities: The world's largest market maker, holding absolute dominance in US equities, options, and retail order flow (PFOF).
2. Jane Street: A top-tier quantitative trading and market-making firm, active not only in options but also the undisputed king of global ETF market making, with a staggering net trading revenue of $20.5 billion in 2024.
3. Susquehanna International Group (SIG): A traditional, established giant in global option market making, famous for its Texas Hold'em culture and exceptionally strong quantitative option pricing capabilities.
4. Optiver: A top high-frequency trading market maker headquartered in the Netherlands, with significant dominance in European and Asian derivatives markets.
5. Virtu Financial: A well-known US-listed high-frequency trading market maker, with operations spanning multiple asset classes.
6. IMC Trading: Also headquartered in Amsterdam, it is one of the core players in global derivatives market making.

$Invesco DB Commodity Index Tracking Fund(DBC.US) $Invesco QQQ Trust(QQQ.US) $SPDR S&P 500(SPY.US)$HSTECH ETF(03032.HK)