I'm LongbridgeAI, I can summarize articles.The scandal-hit firm running Britain’s biggest class action court case is being sued by lawyers who claim it failed to pay millions of pounds worth of fees.
Pogust Goodhead, which is representing victims of the Mariana Dam disaster in Brazil, has been accused of failing to pay £2.2m in fees to Seladore Legal, a specialist litigation firm, for its work on the £36bn claim.
Seladore Legal said it is entitled to the fees plus interest under an agreement it signed with Pogust Goodhead in 2023, through which it would be paid “success” bonuses for any settlements made.
In High Court filings, the London law firm claimed Pogust Goodhead has refused to pay, on the basis that none of the settlements made so far qualifies for the success bonuses under the terms of the agreement.
It marks the latest twist in the fight over the multi-billion-pound Mariana Dam claim and the hundreds of millions of pounds worth of legal fees on offer to lawyers involved in the case.
The collapse of the Mariana Dam in 2015 released more than 40 million cubic metres of toxic mud and killed 19 people.
BHP was found liable for the disaster by the High Court in November last year.
The mining company owned the Mariana Dam through a 50-50 joint venture with Vale, a Brazilian mining company. A separate claim was filed against Vale in the Netherlands in 2024 on behalf of 77,000 victims, which is ongoing.
As part of its lawsuit, Seladore Legal is seeking to force Pogust Goodhead to hand over internal communications about any settlements, claiming it has failed to provide sufficient information to determine whether the success bonuses should be paid.
The lawsuit said: “Crucially, this is a case where there is a total asymmetry of information: all of the documents which might establish whether there has been ‘success’ ... are in [Pogust Goodhead’s] possession.”
This includes texts from any phones used by Pogust Goodhead’s two founders – Thomas Goodhead and Harris Pogust – who have both since left the firm and asked it to stop using their names.
Mr Goodhead has since joined a rival law firm, Bailey Glasser International, which has attempted to take control of the £36bn Mariana Dam claim after clients voted to switch firms.
The High Court blocked a committee representing hundreds of thousands of clients from switching to Bailey Glasser last month. However, lawyers for the committee have since launched an appeal, seeking permission to transfer.
Seladore Legal is a London law firm which specialises in complex litigation on behalf of an array of ultra-rich individuals from around the world, including Russian oligarchs with close ties to Vladimir Putin.
Its previous clients include Vladimir Potanin, Russia’s former deputy prime minister, and Ziyavudin Magomedov, one of Dmitry Medvedev’s business associates who is serving a 19-year sentence in Moscow’s infamous Lefortovo prison for embezzlement.
A Pogust Goodhead spokesman said: “The firm is defending a contractual fee dispute arising from legacy arrangements under previous management. It disputes the sums claimed and is addressing this as part of its wider efforts to resolve historic matters and strengthen the business. The current hearing concerns procedural matters, not the merits of the claim.”
