I'm LongbridgeAI, I can summarize articles.According to Zhitong Finance APP, Bernstein's latest industry survey report on data center chillers indicates that market concerns are rising regarding whether next-generation AI data center architectures require chillers. However, through interviews with procurement heads at five hyperscale cloud providers, new cloud service providers, and original equipment manufacturers (OEMs), the firm believes that demand for chillers remains robust and supply continues to be tight, with no "existential crisis" of substitution in the short term. Bernstein maintained its "Outperform" rating for Trane Tech (TT.US) with a price target of $555, and its "Outperform" rating for Johnson Controls (JCI.US) with a price target of $194. It assigned Carrier (CARR.US) a "Market Perform" rating with a price target of $63.
Strong Demand, Tight Supply: Lead Times Up to Approximately 12 to 18 Months
Experts pointed out that chiller lead times have extended to approximately 12 to 18 months, having generally lengthened over the past 1 to 1.5 years. Bottlenecks are not limited to OEM production capacity but also involve key sub-components such as fans, compressors, and controls, as well as customization and engineering requirements. Some relief may emerge as OEMs expand production and constraints on sub-component procurement ease, but short-term supply remains tight.
Johnson Controls Scores Highest Among Large Chiller/HVAC OEMs
In Bernstein's expert scorecard, Johnson Controls ranked highest overall, followed closely by Carrier and Trane Tech. Johnson Controls received particularly positive feedback on its product and service capabilities, including its extensive field service network. Carrier also performed well in service capabilities, but feedback on functionality and delivery was mixed. Trane Tech's product functionality and quality remained robust, but experts rated its cost and delivery lower, with one expert citing delays in supplier purchase orders and internal coordination issues (involving Stellar's chiller manufacturing division). Japan's Daikin is generally considered cost-competitive with solid functionality and quality, but feedback on delivery was mixed.
Service Is Important, But Not a Moat for OEMs
OEMs remain the preferred choice during the warranty period and for mission-critical work, but most experts are willing to use third-party service providers post-warranty, citing greater bandwidth, faster response times, stronger geographic proximity, and sometimes lower costs. One expert believed that third-party service providers are better equipped to meet strict response time requirements (some hyperscale cloud providers require approximately 4 hours). This aligns with Bernstein's previous analysis of the chiller OEM service landscape: Johnson Controls has the largest North American commercial service network with 270 locations, Trane Tech has 143, and Carrier has 88. However, all three cover the vast majority of existing data center capacity (over 80% within a 30-mile radius).
Chillers Will Not Disappear in the Short Term, But Marginal Demand May Decrease
Experts unanimously pointed out that chillers cannot be completely replaced in the short term due to constraints such as climate, workload mix, and reliability/redundancy requirements. Dry coolers perform poorly in hotter climates (such as Phoenix and Dallas), not all workloads adopt liquid cooling, and mechanical refrigeration still makes sense for a broader range of facilities and electrical equipment. Therefore, the operators interviewed continue to budget for chillers in their multi-year roadmap future designs.
