I'm LongbridgeAI. Here is the key information I extracted- Despite reporting third-quarter revenue that more than doubled to $115.84 billion and a low PEG ratio of 0.2 times, Nvidia shares traded down 36% from their record close following co-founder Jensen Huang's exit and growing competition.…
In Greek myth, Icarus got wings of feathers and wax and one warning: do not fly too close to the sun.
He flew higher anyway. The wax melted, and he fell into the sea.
Wall Street has its own version, and Michael Cembalest of J.P. Morgan Asset & Wealth Management keeps score.
Since 1960, 10 companies have climbed to the top of the S&P 500. Nvidia Corp. (NASDAQ:NVDA) got there faster than any of them.
Its weight in the index rose from roughly 1% in December 2022 to about 8.5% in May 2026, according to Cembalest’s latest Eye on the Market report, titled “The Icarus Files.”
Then the descent began.
Nvidia shares traded near $152.14 on Wednesday, about 36% below their record close of $239.24 on Oct. 6. The stock is down 18.4% this year, while the VanEck Semiconductor ETF (NASDAQ:SMH) is up 26.6% and Advanced Micro Devices Inc. (NASDAQ:AMD) has more than doubled.
Not even a blowout quarter has stopped the slide.
Third-quarter revenue more than doubled to $115.84 billion, and guidance of about $130 billion beat forecasts. The stock jumped as high as $159.70 after the open, then gave the gain back within an hour.
The man who built the company is gone. Co-founder Jensen Huang left amid a China-related controversy, interim CEO Colette Kress led Tuesday’s earnings call, the first since Huang’s exit, and the board has ruled out Huang’s return.
Read Also: Fund Managers Are Dumping Tech Stocks at the Fastest Pace Since 2006
Life at the Top Rarely Lasts
Cembalest calls the pattern the Icarus effect.
Most former leaders of the index ended up at a small fraction of their peak weight. Of the 10, only Exxon Mobil Corp. (NYSE:XOM) still accounts for 1% or more of the S&P 500, according to the report.
Cisco is the starkest case.
It held the top spot for just three days in 2000, at a price-to-earnings ratio of about 200 times, according to Cembalest.
Cisco Systems Inc. (NASDAQ:CSCO) closed at a record $80.06 on March 27, 2000. By October 2002, it had fallen as low as $8.12, a loss of nearly 90%.
The stock did not close above that peak again until Dec. 10, 2025, more than 25 years later.
Why Nvidia Stock Is Not Cisco in 2000
Cisco fell from 200 times earnings. Nvidia is falling from one of the cheapest valuations in the AI trade.
“Nvidia now trades at the lowest valuation among large AI stocks,” Cembalest said in the report.
Cembalest puts Nvidia’s PEG ratio, which divides the price-to-earnings multiple by expected earnings growth, at 0.2 times. Nvidia also earned 83% of AI chip revenue from 2023 to 2025, with a 75% gross margin, according to the report.
Bank of America Global Research made a similar case after the results. The bank reiterated its Buy rating and $280 price target, calling the stock’s valuation a “generational low” at under 10 times its 2027 earnings estimate, against a 30 times median.
The Real Threat Is Not the CEO
For Cembalest, the leadership change is not the main risk. Competition is.
A frontier AI lab cited in the report said that moving its models onto AMD chips used to take six to 12 months. It now takes about three days, partly because AI models handle much of the engineering work.
If customers can switch in days, Nvidia’s moat gets shallower.
Of the seven largest buyers of AI accelerators, only SpaceX is not designing its own silicon, according to the report.
Read Also: Tech Stocks Wipe Out $960 Billion as Washington Shuts China's AI Chip Back Door in 5 Countries
Cembalest still sees Nvidia as interesting for long-term holders at these levels, and says the AI spending boom is far from over. Nvidia’s Rubin Ultra chip, due in 2027, could also restore its performance lead, according to the report.
Melting Wax or a Rising Sun?
Icarus’s wings were not badly made. He simply flew where the heat was too strong for them.
Nvidia’s wings still look strong: record revenue, high margins and a large cash pile.
The market is now pricing the heat: rivals catching up, a Washington hostile to its China ties and a company learning to fly without its founder.
The higher a stock climbs, the less room it has for error.
NVDA Price Action: Nvidia shares were down 2.14% at $152.14 at the time of publication Wednesday, according to Benzinga Pro data.
Photo: Photo Spirit / Shutterstock
Login to unlock2,999characters for free
Due to copyright restrictions, please log in to your Longbridge account to view this content.
Thank you for your understanding and support of licensed content.
