Fed October minutes: A narrow victory

LongbridgeAII'm LongbridgeAI. Here is the key information I extracted
- The Federal Reserve released the minutes of its late October FOMC meeting, revealing that the decision to maintain the federal funds rate target range at 3.75 % to 4 % was a close call with a 10 to 2 vote.
- Participants indicated that further rate hikes may be appropriate in coming months based on inflation and labor market outlooks, while highlighting financial stability risks from rapidly growing debt linked to artificial intelligence infrastructure.…
Disclaimer

Overnight and this morning, Bitcoin turned downwards again, approaching 62k again, almost touching the low of last Sunday (62k).

At 3 a.m., the Federal Reserve released the minutes of the FOMC meeting at the end of October.

The minutes concluded that no interest rate would be raised, as had already been announced after the meeting, and the minutes themselves were a delayed disclosure of more details of the meeting. The target range for the federal funds rate remained at 3.75% to 4%, and the vote was 10 in favor and 2 against[1]. The dissenting votes were from Governor Lisa Cook and Cleveland Fed President Beth Hammack, both of whom advocated for an immediate 25 basis point rate hike.

10 to 2, which seems to be an overwhelming majority.

But the minutes say this about the vote: Several participants who supported keeping the interest rate unchanged said they considered the decision a close call.[1] The weight of the word "close call" is that it acknowledges the possibility of another outcome. The reason for not raising the rate in October was not because the committee was convinced it shouldn't have, but because most people wanted to see more data. The statement also left room for maneuver, saying that the accumulation of more information would help the committee determine the appropriate policy stance, and added at the end that the committee would achieve price stability. The direction was also very clear. Almost all participants judged that, based on their baseline outlook for inflation and the labor market, it would be appropriate to further raise the target range for the interest rate in the coming months. Two others mentioned that if the inflation data was unfavorable, the next meeting could even consider a rate hike of more than 25 basis points.[1] Interest rate futures market pricing indicates that the expectation of a 25 basis point rate hike in December is very strong, with the next meeting scheduled for December 8-9 [4]. The real disagreement lies in the magnitude. Around the time the minutes were released, Federal Reserve Governor Christopher Waller made a more aggressive statement on television. He said he was very, very worried about inflation, that it was going in the wrong direction and that it was spreading. He advocated a one-time 50 basis point rate hike in December, or just 25 basis points, but made it clear to the market that there would be another one in January. In his own words, perhaps it would be necessary to “shock” people and break the psychological expectation of businesses and consumers that a 3% increase was the norm [4]. The market still priced in a 50 basis point rate hike. The 25 basis point increase has been fully priced in, and whether or not it is increased will have little marginal impact on prices; the 50 basis point increase is far from fully priced in [2]. Once the subsequent inflation data is not good (such as the October PCE released at the end of November), those in the committee who advocate for a larger rate hike will have a reason, while the market is almost unprepared for this.

The risk is often not in consensus expectations, but in the unexpected.

This minutes also has another clue that is easily overshadowed by the discussion of rate hikes.

This meeting dedicated a session to discussing financial stability. The staff pointed out one thing in the report: the debt related to artificial intelligence infrastructure is growing rapidly, a considerable part of which is completed through off-balance-sheet lease commitments and revolving financing arrangements. If the returns on AI investments are disappointing, these structures will amplify the risk of losses.

The reactions of the participants are more noteworthy. Almost all participants discussed the scenario where AI investment returns fell short of expectations. Most pointed out that such debt was growing rapidly and was structurally complex and opaque. A few mentioned that AI-related risk exposure was concentrating on a few companies[1]. In the same document, AI was placed in two positions. On the one hand, officials believed that the demand brought about by AI infrastructure could become an important source of inflation; on the other hand, the valuation and debt of AI-related assets became a risk point for financial stability. Rising AI spending both pushed up inflation and supported asset prices. Both of these things were true at the same time. The Federal Reserve only had one tool to deal with this, which was interest rates. Raising interest rates could suppress inflation, but it would also directly impact asset prices. In the past two years, the market has regarded AI as the driving force for everything. The stock market relied on it, risk appetite relied on it, and even the pie narrative benefited from it. For the first time, the Federal Reserve explicitly stated in the FOMC minutes that the debt structure of this investment may be problematic, and that the risk exposure is concentrating on a few companies. This prediction of structural risk may not yet be priced into the market. Looking back at the recent lows, a deeper understanding emerges. Yesterday, I wrote an article titled "Surrender Signals Appear, 62k as the Last Line of Defense." The article's assessment was that most of those who needed to cut their losses had done so, and buyers hadn't yet entered the market. Overnight market action validated both sides of this assessment; 62k was touched again, followed by buying support, and the price recovered slightly. Why are buyers still hesitant to enter the market in large numbers? The answer may lie in these minutes. Whether to raise interest rates in December, and by how much, is still undecided by the Federal Reserve itself. Which large sum of money would be willing to gamble in such an uncertain situation? The current reading of the Fear & Greed Index is 10, which is considered extreme fear. This reading has remained below 20 for nearly a week [3]. Net capital outflows over the past thirty days have reached nearly $8.7 billion [2], and US spot ETFs saw another $240 million outflow in a single day [5]. Yesterday, oil prices fell on their own, with WTI crude oil dropping from $86 to around $83, a drop of about 3.6% in one day [6]. If this trend continues, inflationary pressures will ease, and the necessity for a December rate hike will not seem as strong as it does now. The minutes concluded the policy discussion by saying that future policy decisions depend on the balance of new data, changing prospects, and risks. The October victory was a narrow one. Will there be another narrow victory in December?

Source: CoinLive The copyright of this article belongs to the original author/organization.

The views expressed herein are solely those of the author and do not reflect the stance of the platform. The content is intended for investment reference purposes only and shall not be considered as investment advice. Please contact us if you have any questions or suggestions regarding the content services provided by the platform.